الذنوب والمعاصي تضر ولابد، فإن مما اتفق عليه العلماء وأرباب السلوك أن للمعاصي آثارا وثارات، وأن لها عقوبات على قلب العاصي وبدنه، وعلى دينه وعقله، وعلى دنياه وآخرته.

اختيار هذا الخط


الذنوب والمعاصي تضر ولابد، فإن مما اتفق عليه العلماء وأرباب السلوك أن للمعاصي آثارا وثارات، وأن لها عقوبات على قلب العاصي وبدنه، وعلى دينه وعقله، وعلى دنياه وآخرته.

اختيار هذا الخط

Hasan-Ghareeb hadeeth acceptable to At-Tirmithi

  • 459

    Question

    Greetings again, Scholars. I saw your latest answer on the Hasan-Ghareeb (good-strange) hadith according to At-Tirmidhi, and you laid down its definition as meeting the conditions of Hasan but having something different in its text. However, you did not say if a Hasan-Ghareeb hadith is considered weak or authentic/reliable according to At-Tirmidhi. Due to this, I was wondering, is the Hasan-Ghareeb hadith considered reliable or not by At-tirmidhi? Please do not give me a link to another fatwa, as you did not address this specific question in the previous one.

    Answer

    All perfect praise be to Allah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad, , is His slave and Messenger.

    The statement of Imaam At-Tirmithi on the hadeeth, that it is Hasan-Ghareeb, means that this hadeeth is acceptable to him and not weak; rather, it is stronger than the hadeeth regarding which he says Hasan only without the term Ghareeb.

    Al-Albaani said, "The hadeeth about which At-Tirmithi says Hasan-Ghareeb is stronger than the hadeeth about which he says Hasan only. That is because the former means that it is Hasan in and of itself (Hasan li-thaatih), while the latter means that it is Hasan by the support of other ahaadeeth (Hasan li-ghayrih).

    At-Tirmithi clarified (his terminology of) the Hasan hadeeth at the end of his book As-Sunan, and Ibn Hajar highlighted it in Sharh An-Nukhbah (p. 11 – Al-Maymaniyyah), and then he declared (on p. 25) that this kind of hadeeth is inferior to the rank of Hasan li-thaatih [i.e. Hasan Ghareeb]."

    Allah knows best.

    Related Material

    Fatwas

    Search Fatwa

    You can search for fatwa through many choices